The first published responses of religious writers, poets and thinkers who survived the holocaust were generally based on this paradoxthey expressed a traumatized belief which, standing the trial of the holocaust, was too profound to be pacified by any of the ready. The jack, joseph and morton mandel center for advanced holocaust studies is a leading generator of new knowledge and understanding of the holocaust. Within all of the monotheistic faiths many answers theodicies have been proposed. The source materials for many of the books published during the immediate postwar period were the notes and diaries kept by many camp and ghetto dwellers, who were sustained during their unbelievable ordeal by the unusual. Night is the archetypal holocaust novel, in many ways more an experience that you have, rather than a book that you read. In an essay titled bubers concept of holocaust and history, david glanz had this to say about bubers silence. The third and final part of philosophical witnessing, the presence as future, reflects on some of the ways the holocaust has shapedand may continue to shapeboth institutions and. These developments could be seen as either continuations of or breaks from the canon of rabbinic philosophy of the middle ages, as well as the other historical dialectic aspects of jewish thought, and resulted in. Morgan, benjamin pollock responses to fackenheims reflections on the centrality of the holocaust to philosophy, jewish thought, and contemporary experience. The holocaust encyclopedia is the only comprehensive singlevolume work of reference providing both a reflective overview of the subject and abundant detail concerning major events, policy decisions, cities, and individuals.
A jewish philosophers response to the holocaust philosophy kindle edition by patterson, david. The most comprehensive and representative collection of its kind, a holocaust reader. In the varied responses to modernity, jewish philosophical ideas were developed across the range of emerging religious movements. Fiftyfive years after the fact the world still ponders the enormity of this disaster. Which of these responses seems most meaningful to you, and why. The book, the permission to destroy life unworthy of life by karl binding described the mentally ill, the feebleminded and the retarded as unworthy of life, and therefore encouraged eugenics. The holocaust and the book university of massachusetts press. His book detailed the psychological reactions that an inmate progressed. This important book, which consists of twelve essays.
The contributors to this book dare to extend that questioning through a critical. Jewish philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust during the holocaust some six million jews were murdered and jewish life in europe was virtually destroyed. The educational philosoph y of idealism is one of the oldest educational. Uptodate and designed for easy access, the encyclopedia presents information on the major aspects of the holocaust in. Philosophical responses to the holocaust at university of toronto. Up to date and designed for easy access, the encyclopedia presents information on the major aspects of the holocaust in. The holocaust encyclopedia by judith tydor baumel 2001.
The journal of philosophy, volume 82, issue 10, eightysecond annual meeting american philosophical association, eastern division oct. Response to richard dawkinss comments on my writings in his book the god delusion. The holocaust has been the subject of countless books, works of art, and memorials. Philosophical responses to the holocaust philosophy senior seminar phil 430001w, fall 2019 contact info and meeting times instructor dr. The inner antisemitism of philosophy and german jewish responses, michael mack is published by university of. I am grateful to richard dawkins for having looked at some of my writings. Aaron berman, nazism, the jews and american zionism, 19331948 1990. Apr 10, 2001 the book also has more than 250 photographs, many of them rare, and 19 maps. More importantly, the chapter looks at the rebuilding of jewish life and the role of israel. Night by elie wiesel, the book thief by markus zusak, the diary of a young girl by anne frank, the boy in the striped pajamas. In the years immediately after world war ii, the holocaust was little studied. He is specifically concerned with returning to the question of the holocaust as a philosophical problem and thinking about how fackenheims and his responses to this issue can set an agenda for future jewish thought. Response to dawkins the god delusion university of oxford.
Most of that issues ten contributors had backgrounds in philosophy, and as in most other issues, most articles used an analytical philosophical approach. The existential angst of job is an example from the hebrew bible of the existentialist theme. Analysis of the holocaust and philosophy by adam watson 2002 fackenheim, emil l. Two recent books reflect contrasting approaches to the study of the holocaust.
The answer seems to lie in the nazi weltanschauung, whose granite. The fallwinter 198485 issue was a double one on the holocaust. The most comprehensive overview of theological and philosophical responses to the holocaust is katz, et al. Here are very brief responses to the objections which he quite properly raises. The first and most tightly focused of these, the holocaust at philosophys address, includes chapters on philosophical witnessing, the implications of the holocaust for understanding the nature of truth, philosophical and theological responses to the problem of evil in the context of jewish history and metahistory, and a discussion of karl. The nature of this event, and the particularity and peculiarity of its assault. Steven katz, professor of jewish holocaust studies at boston university and former director of the elie wiesel center for jewish studies. The holocaust encyclopedia baumel judith tydor laqueur. During the holocaust some six million jews were murdered and jewish life in. It surveys the major themes raised by the holocaust and examines the most provocative and influential responses to these topics and to. This section includes film footage of the eichmann trial and the nuremberg trials along with coverage of the eventual fate of key nazi leaders. Even more traditional terms have acquired novel connotations in the. The holocaust encylopedia is the only comprehensive singlevolume work of reference providing both a reflective overview of the subject and abundant detail concerning major events, policy, decisions, cities, and individuals, up to date and designed for easy access, the encyclopedia presents information on the major aspects of the holocaust in. The uniqueness of the holocaust my jewish learning.
Several authors discuss the continuing relevance of nazi book burnings to the present day, with essays on german responses to friedrich nietzsche and the destruction of bosnian libraries in the 1990s. Fackenheim and responses to the holocaust ebook written by michael l. Jewish philosophical and theological responses to the. Access study documents, get answers to your study questions, and connect with real tutors for rlg 220h1. A jewish philosophers response to the holocaust philosophy patterson, david on. The holocaust encyclopedia is a good example of what could be called the macro approach, which includes generalized histories, lexicons and collections of archival and research findings. Philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust. A hypermedia sourcebook for the humanities, we will be examining the philosophical responses to the shoah that have emerged since 1945. In this revealing book, david patterson explores fackenheims rigorous pursuit of a philosophical response to the tragedy of the holocaust. Seven responses to the holocaust in american fiction.
The nature of this event, and the particularity and peculiarity of its assault against jewish life and jewish dignity. The first and most tightly focused of these, the holocaust at philosophys address, includes chapters on philosophical witnessing, the implications of the holocaust for understanding the nature of truth, philosophical and theological responses to the problem of evil in the context of jewish history and metahistory, and a discussion of. This readable onevolume work offers an extensive chronology of historical turning points during the nazi. In a short history of philosophy, the most accessible concise portrait of philosophy in seventy years, robert solomon and kathleen higgins meet the challenge of accurately and engagingly describing it all, revelling in philosophy as the art of wonder, the. Holocaust theology refers to a body of theological and philosophical debate, soulsearching, and analysis, with the subsequent related literature, that attempts to come to grips with various conflicting views about the role of god in this human world and the events of the european holocaust that occurred during world war ii 19391945 when around 11 million people. He engaged in the pursuit of the philosophical implications of the slaughter of the jewish people on jewish thought, judaism, the jewish people, the state of israel, and on philosophy itself. University press of new england for brandeis university press, 2009, 260 pp.
They stated that many were merely shells of humans and that it was a healing act to kill them. The interviewer had doubted stangls first answer, but ac cepted his. Jews were killed in higher proportions than other groups. Nazi ideology and ethics, edited by wolfgang bialas and lothar fritze. The overwhelming nature of the nazi atrocities and the jewish losses in the holocaust has compelled the post. The centrality of the holocaust in the study of the third reich and the nazi phenomenon is almost universally recognized. From sophisticated philosophical analyses of nazism to pronazi apologias, the book shows how nazism informed debates over culture and politics in britain, and how before the war and the holocaust made nazism anathema it was often discussed in ways that now seem surprising. Historically, postholocaust thought in theology and philosophy emerged primarily in the 1960s and. Steven katz, professor of jewish holocaust studies at boston university and former director of the elie wiesel center for jewish studies, introduces the best. Nazi ideology and ethics, edited by wolfgang bialas and lothar fritze this book first published 2014 cambridge scholars publishing 12 back chapman street, newcastle upon tyne, ne6 2xx, uk british library cataloguing in publication data a catalogue record for this book is available from the british library. The museums collections document the fate of holocaust victims, survivors, rescuers, liberators, and others through artifacts, documents, photos, films, books, personal stories, and more. Oxford university press holocaust reader md responses. Always update books hourly, if not looking, search in the book search column. Gail herman traces the rise of hitler and the nazis, whose rabid antisemitism led first to humiliating antijewish laws, then to ghettos all over eastern europe, and ultimately to the final.
Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read philosopher as witness, the. As with the postholocaust theologians who followed, thinkers such as abraham isaac kook and mordecai kaplan mediated traditional jewish theology with the specific challenges of the modern world. Popular holocaust books meet your next favorite book. As far as a reference it is an excellent book to have in your library if you are a holocaust nonfiction book collector or world war ii enthusiast i have many world war ii books especially about the holocaust and this one is very compelling and extremely informative so i would recommend it 100%. The holocaust encylopedia is the only comprehensive singlevolume work of reference providing both a reflective overview of the subject and abundant detail concerning major events, policy, decisions, cities.
As with the post holocaust theologians who followed, thinkers such as abraham isaac kook and mordecai kaplan mediated traditional jewish theology with the specific challenges of the modern world. Philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust jewish. The philosophical forum usually has four or five articles per issue. Religious and philosophical implications is an anthology specifically designed for use as a textbook for courses on the holocaust in universities and adult study groups. It is a compilation of what are now classic pieces in the voluminous literature on the holocaust pieces by raul hilberg, hannah arendt, primo levi, george steiner, richard rubenstein and. It surveys the major themes raised by the holocaust and examines the most provocative and influential. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Learning from history and the holocaust encyclopedia the. Patterson states that in addition to presenting fackenheims thought, he also seeks to extend it. Holocaust survivor, psychiatrist and author viktor frankl. Is levinass philosophy a response to the holocaust.
Rosenberg 1992 has the same focus but is less comprehensive. Students will respond to a question and be divided into groups based on their responses. Religious and philosophical implications, in addition to being organized around the five themes identified above, addresses the multiple implications of complexities such as resistance during the holocaust, and jewish and christian identity after auschwitz. Jan 01, 2001 the holocaust encyclopedia is the only comprehensive singlevolume work of reference providing both a reflective overview of the subject and abundant detail concerning major events, policy decisions, fiftyfive years after the fact the world still ponders the enormity of this disaster. Raul hilberg on concentration camps and gypsies ruth bondy, israel gutman, and dina porat on major ghettoes roger greenspun on the holocaust in cinema and television richard breitman on american policy. Philosophical stance that the world can be divided into subsets of people, and that the germans, in particular, should have a very specific identity. Leventhal department of german university of virginia. Holocaust theology is a body of theological and philosophical debate concerning the role of. Philosophical responses have taken on three central forms.
Finally, it examines the responses to the holocaust. The programs on ethics, religion, and the holocaust are supported by the hoffberger family foundationand by joseph a. Jewish existentialism is a category of work by jewish authors dealing with existentialist themes and concepts e. The nature of this event, and the particularity and peculiarity of its assault against jewish life and jewish dignity, force a. The collection also includes eyewitness accounts by holocaust survivors and a translation of herman kruks report on the vilna ghetto library. Responses to the nazi extermination features writings by theologians, literary figures, cultural critics, philosophers, political theorists, and others. Holocaust theology refers to a body of theological and philosophical debate, soulsearching, and analysis, with the subsequent related literature, that attempts to come to grips with various conflicting views about the role of god in this human world and the events of the european holocaust that occurred during world war ii 19391945 when around 11 million people, including 6 million jews. A jewish philosophers response to the holocaust philosophy. Governed by the thesis that the holocaust left fundamental questions, holocaust. Childrens book stalwart lois lowry earned the 1990 newbury medal for this memorable tale about a 10yearold girl whose jewish best friend is threatened by the rise of nazism in 1943 denmark. The philosophical implications of the holocaust springerlink. What are the essential features of the jewish dietary code kashrut. Viktor frankls book on the psychology of the holocaust to be made. Proper answers to the objections are to be found in the other writings of mine to which i refer below.
Your subscription doesnt include the subject of this book. America and the refugee crisis, 19381941 1968 and the abandonment of the jews. Some pre holocaust responses to evil and suffering modern thinkers confronted the problem of evil and suffering long before the holocaust. Inform students that they will discuss the assigned reading with an activity called philosophical chairs. Search below to view digital records and find material that you can access at our library and at the shapell center. However, the third reich, not merely its holocaust component, was the only. Fackenheim and responses to the holocaust michael l. Part of the library of philosophy and religion book series lpr. They will then discuss their reasons for their answers. That all changed with the publication of raul hilbergs book, the destruction of the european jews.
Responses to the holocaust quiz1 flashcards quizlet. The holocaust encyclopedia is the only comprehensive singlevolume work of reference providing both a reflective overview of the subject and abundant detail concerning major events, policy decisions, fiftyfive years after the fact the world still ponders the enormity of. The holocaust and the book university of massachusetts. Its author, elie wiesel, was born in what is now romania and survived several concentration camps, and in night, he puts into hauntingly beautiful words all of the terrible events, whether physical, mental, or emotional, that he had to survive. In a short history of philosophy, the most accessible concise portrait of philosophy in seventy years, robert solomon and kathleen higgins meet the challenge of accurately and engagingly describing it all, revelling in philosophy as the art of. Eckardt he holocaust is, by itself, such an enormity in the questions it raises that this survey of christian and jewish responses cannot possibly do complete justice to any of the views represented. Get ebooks the holocaust on pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi and audiobook for free. Philosophy is a singularly expansive enterprise, a fascinating outgrowth of a human nature that demands we question who and why we are. Two other wellknown approaches which yield a similar sterile outcome concern 1 a mystification which ensues from treating the holocaust as essentially unthinkable owing to its extrahistorical and profoundly idiosyncratic evil nature. It is a compilation of what are now classic pieces in the voluminous literature on the holocaust pieces by raul hilberg, hannah arendt, primo levi, george. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading emil l. Philosophical reflections on genocide and the claim. Holocaust theology is a body of theological and philosophical debate concerning the role of god in the universe in light of the holocaust of the late 1930s and 1940s. There are more than 1 million books that have been enjoyed by people from all over the world.
The book, the permission to destroy life unworthy of life by karl binding described the mentally ill, the feebleminded. Philosophical reflections on genocide and the claim about the uniqueness of the holocaust. However, we may benefit more from considering this wider range of views than if we were to. Jewish philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust. The holocaust was a genocide on a scale never before seen, with as many as twelve million people killed in nazi death campssix million of them jews. What effect does strict adherence to this code have on ones behavior. Essentially, philosophical chairs is a means of debating an issue. Rubenstein and roth 1987 includes varieties of religious response to the holocaust in orthodox and liberal jewish and christian. Discuss three philosophical responses to the shoah. The best books on the holocaust recommended by steven katz.
292 189 1044 1332 841 542 871 833 526 358 550 410 779 916 761 953 1312 1627 796 146 1245 425 681 308 18 1288 933 1225 746 69 474